I’m considering changing the ability buttons’ art style from those shown on the right (images 2,4, and 6 are currently used ability icons) to those on the left.
The current buttons don’t have a uniform style, although most have the white and green style shown in image 6. I have a theory that white and green clash too much and don’t look good. Then again they might be kinda cool because of that. I’m not sure.
The checkered background is transparent and would be replaced by the game.
Image 4 shows the original art style, filled in green. Image 2 shows an alternative art style that shows more details instead of filling things in. Image 5 highlights the insides of solid objects in the drawing. The new images on the left column are a bit of a mix of all of these, and allow the user to see through the buttons too.
So which do you think looks better? 1 or 2? 3 or 4? 5 or 6?
Or should I change them all to the style in image 2? or image 4, or 6?